In a bitter tone, The Giver tells Jonas that the rule about release was added after the Receiver-in-training's failure ten years earlier.At Jonas' request, The Giver finally explains what happened to the earlier Receiver, who was named Rosemary.But one day, after receiving a few painful memories, Rosemary said goodbye to The Giver, left the Annex, and asked to be released.Grief stricken and angry over the loss of Rosemary, The Giver was unable to help the community through its ordeal.Knowing that memories will destroy the community's Sameness, Jonas asks The Giver a hypothetical question: "What if I fell into the river .Again Lowry foreshadows the future as she concludes Chapter 18 with The Giver deep in thought about Jonas' suggestion to help the community experience freedom once again.Suspense builds as The Giver insists in a very firm voice that Jonas be quiet and watch the video recording of the release.After the video ends, The Giver tells Jonas that Rosemary asked to inject herself at her release.When he realizes that his father lies about what releasing a baby means, The Giver sadly explains, "It's what he was told to do, and he knows nothing else.".By describing the baby's release, a most senseless and horrifying death, Lowry reveals that the community practices infanticide, the killing of infants.Rosemary's suicide reveals that the community also practices a form of euthanasia — here, meaning that a person voluntarily asks to die.However, in the community, release for the elderly or as punishment for citizens who have broken the rules is a form of forced euthanasia, or murder.The emotional climax of the novel is when Jonas finally becomes aware of the true meaning of release and realizes that the community's ideals are far from being idealistic.The falling action of the novel — in literary terms, known as de-nouement — begins as The Giver and Jonas decide that things in the community must change, that neither one of them can tolerate the people's Sameness and blind obedience any longer.Jonas and The Giver talk until very late, developing a plan to save the people in the community from their own senseless inhumanity.The people in the community will notice Jonas' absence; they will search and assume he's fallen into the river, as the four-year-old Caleb did years earlier.Lowry concludes Chapter 20 by showing the love and affection that Jonas and The Giver have for one another.The Giver tells Jonas that after he helps the people in the community cope with their newly found memories, he wants to be with his daughter, Rosemary, who, we now learn, was the earlier Receiver-in-training who chose death over living a lonely and isolated life filled with painful memories. .

In The Giver who is Rosemary?

The Giver tells Jonas that he loved Rosemary, but he had to impart such memories as loneliness to her.It is then that the Giver reveals to Jonas that Rosemary injected herself, committing suicide, and that she was his daughter. .

The Giver Chapters 17–18 Summary & Analysis

Four weeks after Jonas stops taking his pills, an unscheduled holiday is declared in the community.He tries to explain to his friends that the game is a cruel mockery of a horrible reality, but they are only puzzled and annoyed.Jonas cannot ask for release either, a rule that was created after the failure of the new Receiver ten years ago.When Rosemary’s training began, she loved experiencing new things, and the Giver started with happy memories that would make her laugh.The Giver could not bring himself to give her physical pain, but at her insistence he gave her loneliness, loss, poverty, and fear.Jonas knows that he cannot apply for release, but he asks the Giver what would happen if he accidentally drowned in the river, carrying a year’s worth of memories with him.Since Jonas suffered death and pain through the Giver’s memories, we might expect him to suspect the truth.His time with the Giver has made him aware of what his community does not offer (color, desire, pain), but it has not revealed any of the secrets concealed beneath his society’s veneer of tranquility.Rosemary was an appropriate choice for Receiver, but the fact that after her failure it was forbidden to speak her name again is telling: after their unpleasant experience dealing with all of Rosemary’s released memories, the community wanted nothing to do with remembrance, and their rejection of her name constitutes a double rejection of memory.He subjects Jonas to a broken leg, starvation, and war wounds, but these agonies eventually subside.Release from the community could be shameful or painful, but it would also mean a kind of escape from an oppressive, limiting society.As we will see in later chapters, Jonas manages to physically leave the community alive, to actually explore Elsewhere. .

Why did Rosemary request release? Do you think that Rosemary

It was her inability to cope with and accept these difficult memories of humanity's past that made her decide to request release.Clearly, Rosemary showed great bravery in freely accepting, and self-administering, the "Release" that she wanted to forget all the painful memories she had received. .


Leave a reply

your email address will not be published. required fields are marked *

Name *
Email *